As a child of the 70's, I grew up on the "ministry of every believer" constantly being emphasized in church. This occurred in concert with the cry to elimate the clergy-laity distinction that had so characterized the church of the past.
Revelation 1:6 (NAS) -- "and He has made us to be a kingdom of priests to His God and Father..."
I rejoiced in this, that all believers were now priests unto God in Christ, thus elimating the need for human intermediaries. And yet human intermediaries remained: the pastor, who spoke on God's behalf at weddings and funerals; the prophet, who revealed God's heart to his people; the teacher, who illuminated and explained the mysteries of the scriptures.
And while scripture affirms the egalitarian nature of the body of Christ (e.g. 1 Cor.12:12-13), it also abounds with examples of individuals, uniquely called and placed in positions of leadership and responsiblity for others.
1 Timothy 3:1 (RSV) -- "The saying is sure: whoever aspires to the office of bishop desires a noble task."
Hebrews 13:7 (NIV) -- "Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they keep watch over your souls and will give an account..."
The paradoxes of scripture have always fascinated me, and this one is no exception. The ministry of every believer is a critically important doctrine that still needs to be expounded upon within our communities of faith. Yet, I'm wondering how modern, cultural individualism, may have undermined the uniqueness of the clergy.
Six years ago, I entered the Free Methodist family of faith. One of the things I love about our denomination is the balance between having equal numbers clergy and laity in its administrative boards at every level (local, conference, national), while at the same time strongly affirming its episcopal form of church governance.
After 30 years of pastoral ministry, I've come to more deeply appreciate and be awed by the unique privilege of serving as a minister/pastor/priest. I celebrate the diversity of "ministries" that God calls the members of his body to, and I've never let go of the belief that while we all have different occupations, we share a common vocation as ministers. However, the scriptures present a clergy-laity reality that is not radically egalitarian. Men and women do occupy positions of responsibility for others, and are vested with an authority to carry out that responsibility.
Yes, we live in an age of horrible abuses by members of the clergy (mental, spiritual, sexual, financial). But such offences should spur us on to redeem the holy offices of deacon, pastor, bishop, rather than dispense with them. In the corner of God's kingdom where I grew up, we need to re-affirm the sacredness of the clergy-laity distinction -- not for the purpose of marginalizing or victimizing others, but in order to affirm and nurture the godly, competant leaders our spiritually-hungry society needs.