Are We Too Sophisticated for Weekly Communion?
April 13, 2008
Are we too sophisticated for weekly communion? By "sophisticated", I mean, are we fully committed to casting aside the overwhelming tradition of the Church-through-the-ages in favor of our own higher thinking, our own clever reasoning? A reasoning that asserts, "If we take communion every week, it will become cheap, ordinary, mundane, and meaningless.
Is our sophisticated reasoning really a better way to go? Is such sophistication honestly to be preferred over having an attitude of humility that acknowledges something may be wrong in us ? That our own fallen, sinful, selfish heart may be getting in the way and messing-up our ability to commune with Christ through the elements of bread and wine no matter how frequent that might be? Is is possible that our own sophistication and clever reasoning is keeping us from pondering this matter at a deeper level, and in a way that would compel us to take communion as often as possible without lessening its mystery or power?
Now, before you "we-take-communion-once-a-month" folks lay into me, let me say up front that I've come to a place in my journey where I see the oft-cited "cheapening" rationale behind the taking of monthly communion as a straw-man defense -- an accommodation to our human weakness rather than an appeal to either the scriptures or the historical consensus of the church-through-history, and therefore more shameful than defendable or honorable.
If you attend a church whose tradition is to only take Communion occasionally, I am certainly not encouraging any sort of dissonance or rebellion. Rather, I am opening the door for thoughtful contemplation and dialog.
In my own tradition, John Wesley encouraged that Holy Communion be taken as often as possible. Since the Eucharist is a sacrament and a "means of grace", why would I ever want to receive it less frequently?
.
Photo credit: © Andrew Penner, iStockphoto.com